It’s Rule 5 Saturday!

This week features Cheryl Cole and the Speculators!

“How to Get a Million Hits on Your Blog in Less Than a Year!”

Cheryl Cole (34-23-33): Cheryl Ann Cole is an English singer, and member of the band Girls Aloud. Cole is also a judge on the British reality TV show The X Factor since 2008. She is the wife of Chelsea and England footballer Aashley Cole. As part of Girls Aloud and as a featuring artist, Cheryl has managed to place nineteen songs in the UK Top 10.Even before marrying Cashley Cole, she won the title of "Sexiest Footballer's Wife" in FHM's 2006 Bloke Awards, and as Cole's fiancée she was a prominent "WAG" in Germany during the 2006 World Cup.

She married Cole in his home town of St. Albans, Hertfordshire , on 15 July 2006 ... The wedding was paid for by OK! Magazine, who paid the couple £1 million to publish pictures of the wedding. In late January 2008, The Sun newspaper reported that Ashley Cole had been sleeping with several other women during their relationship, and that the couple were in the process of separating.

In May 2010 Cheryl Cole filed for divorce and dropped her surname from new merchandise on her website in preparation for returning to her maiden name, Cheryl Tweedy, once her divorce is granted.

Manute Bol   The Pirate’s Cove   signature pinup

Ashlyn Martin   Gaye Rennie   The Tudors

Yankee Phil   Riehl World View   Debrahlee Lorenzana

Approves   not as furniture   Mourns

- It's the Speculators, Stupid! -

Many commentators (the majority of whom are not economists) blame the imminent crisis in the eurozone on malevolent speculators. I find it necessary to take up the cudgels on the traders' behalf and explain why they are not culpable for the current mess.

A False Battle

There is no better moment for this. The language that European leaders and the media are using in relation to the continent's sovereign-debt crisis diverts the blame away from those responsible, and targets speculators instead: "Merkel and Sarkozy take aim at speculators" (Reuters Germany); "we will defend the Euro at all costs" (José Manuel Barosso); "we believe that not only Greece, Spain, Portugal and Italy are under attack," but that "the whole Euro-zone is being threatened" (Jean Claude-Juncker). German Chancellor Angela Merkel even claimed that "in some ways, it's a battle of the politicians against the markets," adding that "speculators are our enemies," and "I'm determined to win."[1]

Sunday Totty............   Susan Ward   What's for lunch.............

Jules Crittenden   For What It’s Worth   Fausta

Left Bank of the Charles   House of Eratosthenese   Honesty in Motion

Holly Marie Combs   Rosemary Clooney   Happy Feet Friday

This "battle" goes so far that the present article might by now even be considered illegal in France. According to Reuters, French authorities plan to work together with intelligence services to fight "unfounded" rumors about the solvency of European countries.[2]

A Bold Cheer for Speculators

Against this increasingly intimidating zeitgeist, economists should stand up and explain that speculation is in fact a beneficial and essential undertaking in a free society.

First, in the real world, every economic actor is a speculator, as he takes decisions according to his future expectations concerning prices and people's preferences. Each speculator possesses a piece of disperse, subjective, and oftentimes tacit knowledge and reveals this information through his buying actions, which ultimately determine prices. In doing so, multitudes of market participants reveal data that otherwise could not be gathered.[3]

SI VIS PACEM   Hotties   Proper heat

Haemet   charity groin wax   American Power

Second, speculators suffer losses whenever they predict a rise or drop in price that ultimately does not occur. That means if a speculator believes that a country that in reality has no liquidity or solvency problems will default in the near future, he stands to lose a lot of money. Due to this financial incentive, every investor will boldly search for as much information as possible. The result is that the capital market as a whole delivers very accurate signals about competing investment opportunities.

In the present case of sovereign-debt crisis, concern is growing among market participants about whether or not the citizens of the PIIGS (Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, and Spain) will be willing — and able — to pay back their governments' debt. As a result, yields on government bonds as well as on insurance devices like Credit Default Swaps (CDS) rise. The actual cause of this, however, is the underlying fiscal policy of the country in question, and not the speculator's purchase, which is merely a reflection or a result of imprudent decisions taken by politicians in the past.

iOwnTheWorld   occasionally toxic   Dr. Helen

X Ray hottie   Flag Day   Die Wassertragerin

‘Zonie Protest   World Cup   Shania Twain

The Saint Angilbert Press   Yankee Phil   Kelly Brook

In other words, the speculator just fills the opportunity gap that is already there — the seeds of these price movements have already been sown. Speculators become aware of the big hole that governments themselves dug over the recent years. And speculators transmit this knowledge to other market participants by bidding prices on these debt obligations (in the case of bonds) or insurance policies on those obligations (in the case of CDSs) accordingly.

Hence, the capital market's concern and the action of speculators can be compared to a medical thermometer that helps to evaluate the patient's state of health. Would any patient really blame the thermometer for his fever?

Third, it is clear that a speculator has no power whatsoever over anybody. All he can do is offer his financial resources in exchange for the securities he demands. He cannot, unlike politicians, use any type of force in order to gain the object of his desire. Instead, he is fully dependent on the willingness of his counterparty to engage in the exchange. The language of political leaders cited above is therefore misleading; abstaining from further purchases (as in the case of not buying government bonds anymore) or insuring already undertaken risks (as in the case of purchases of CDS) can hardly be called a "battle" or an "attack."

Pit Babes and Grid Girls   Juliana Moreira   here

Fills   Halle Berry   Diablo Cody

That burka commercial   Alejandro Fashion Credits   Trying to kick

Babes of the Twilight Zone 2   Babes of the Twilight Zone 3   Rule 5 Festgate

Don't Blame the Messengers, Blame Those Responsible

Speculators fulfill a vital signaling function in the market process. Their current signals should induce politicians to radically reduce the government's burden on society and return to fiscal discipline as quickly as possible. If anyone is to take the blame for the current mess in which European countries find themselves, it should not be the bearers of bad news but those who steered the affected economies in the unsustainable direction.

Kate Perry   Mind Numbed Robot   Waxing Erratic

Susan Ward   Nicole Eggert   Roselyn Sanchez

Beltway Baseball   Uncoverage   narrative control

Propaganda   The Stunners   Green Light II

The idea that speculators are useless or even harmful is quite old, but nonetheless flawed. Economics teaches that the market's efficiency derives precisely from its ability to gather and make available dispersed knowledge. Speculators are one of the driving forces behind this process. Unfortunately, many commentators, as well as state officials, do not fully comprehend this fact and instead blame the market for Europe's problems. Thus, it is unlikely that the policy proposals they offer will revive a faltering economy.

Dustbury   Proof Positive   American Glob

Hot Chick a Latte   Women of PETA X   Women of PETA XI

Rule 5 Saturday   To an unknown ISP   Saturday night

Pamela the Fabulous   Jenny Agutter   Hayden Panettiere

It's the Speculators, Stupid!

Malte Tobias Kähler writes for a German debating magazine called Novo Argumente. With a master's degree in political science from the University of Münster in Germany, he is currently participating in a postgraduate program in economics under Professor Huerta de Soto at King Juan Carlos University, Madrid.

Also went burkha   Barbara Eden   Claudia Schiffer

Situps   Unofficial Katy Perry   Hot Babe With Gun

Zooey Deschanel   Kylie Minogue   Teri Hatcher

Rethinking striking Iran   The Army’s Birthday   The AFPAK Forecast


[1] "Merkel Invokes Market 'Battle' as Germany votes on Greece," Bloomberg, May 6, 2010. See also, "Merkel und Sarkozy erklären Spekulanten den Krieg," Reuters Germany, May 6, 2010. All emphases are mine.

[2] "France to use intelligence agency in rumor crackdown", Reuters, May 7, 2010.

[3] On the ubiquity of the speculator in the market economy, see Israel Kirzner (2007) Market Theory and Price System, Alabama: Ludwig von Mises Institute, pp. 17–18 and pp. 315–316. On the relationship of knowledge and markets see F.A. Hayek (1980), "The Use of Knowledge in Society," Individualism and Economic Order, Chicago and London: Chicago University Press, pp. 77–91.

Instapundit   Smash Mouth Politics   Power Line

House of Eratosthenes   Left Coast Rebel   Wants

House of Eratosthenes   Left Coast Rebel   Wants

Propaganda   The Stunners   Green Light II

Susan Denberg   Joan Jett   Flag Day!

Miley Cyrus   Denise Milani   Mae West

Skye   Kate Perry   Heidi Klum

Vanderleun   Fishersville Mike   Michigan Blogger

WyBlog   Mean Ol’ Meany   Larissa Riquelme

Katherine Heigl   Alisyn Camerota   Katy Perry

Eye of Polyphemus   At The Point Of A Gun   Nation of Cowards

Rethinking striking Iran   The Army’s Birthday   The AFPAK Forecast

Carrie Keagan   Judy Tyler   Laura Young

Denise Milani   iOwnTheWorld   chicks and guns